NSF Sponsored Workshop for Improving and Assessing the Impact of Programs to Encourage High School Girls to Pursue Science, Engineering, and Mathematics

 

Position Paper

 

By Margaret I. McCarthy, Area Representative and

Coordinator, Math Options Program

Penn State Erie, The Behrend College

Erie, Pennsylvania

 

 

Background

 

The Math Options Program at Penn State Erie was modeled after Penn State’s Abington (Philadelphia) campus, which began there in 1991 under the corporate sponsorship of Bell of Pennsylvania in consultation with the Philadelphia Chapter of Women and Mathematics. The program as expanded across the state of Pennsylvania to many other Penn State locations and now serves over 1500 girls annually. The goal of Math Options is important, as it addresses a problem recognized by a growing number of educators and mentors: young girls need role models and special kinds of encouragement if they are to pursue careers that require a foundation in mathematics.

 

Research indicates that students in the United States are not competitive with students in other countries, especially in the areas of mathematics and science (National Commission on Excellence in Education, 1983; Task Force on Education for Economic Growth, `983; Travers, K.J., McKnight, CC, 1985). Compounding this problem, Workforce 2000 (Johnson, W.B., Packer, A.E., 1987) predicts that the United States will need an additional 500,000 scientists and engineers to remain competitive in the next century. If current demographic trends continue, a majority of the new entrants in this workforce will be women and minorities who traditionally have not pursued careers in science or engineering. It is imperative that we nurture and develop students’ interests and achievement in science and mathematics if we are going to address the nation’s need for expertise in the scientific, engineering, and technological fields.

 

Unfortunately, women are frequently "locked out" of many career options because of an early decision not to study science and mathematics. The American Association of University Women (AAUW), in Shortchanging Girls, Shortchanging America, documents a loss of self-esteem in girls that is reflected in a declining interest in mathematics and science as they progress through the secondary grades. It is necessary to introduce girls to the opportunities and incentives for pursuing careers in mathematics, science, engineering, and technology; for without their participation, "America will be competing with only half its team on the field." (AAUW, 1991). In How Schools Shortchange Girls, the AAUW further recommends that "educational institutions, professional organizations, and the business community work…together to dispel myths about math and science as ‘inappropriate’ fields for women,….by showcasing women role models in scientific and technological fields, disseminating career information, and offering "hands-on" experiences…"(AAUW, 1992).

 

Programming

 

The Math Options Program responds to this challenge. It is a career awareness program for 7th and 8th grade girls highlighting opportunities in these fields. The program brings together young women from 4 different counties surrounding the Penn State Erie campus, Penn State Erie faculty and staff, and professional women from government agencies, businesses, and industries for a yearly one-day event of workshops, career fair, and discussions.

 

Math Options is guided by the Math Options Advisory Committee, made up of Penn State women faculty and women representatives from the community. They meet every other month to advise, plan and participate in Math Options activities, and serve as volunteers and mentors for all program participants. Our Math Options Day, held each year in the month of May, beginning in 1997, features an activity-filled day which includes:

 

of a projection launching pad to catapult a tennis ball, and building a tower out of

straws, tapes, cardboard and other simple items using the laws of physics and gravity.

respective fields. The Math Options 1999 Program featured the Director of

Penn State University’s Women in Science and Engineering (WISE) Institute,

a general manager at the local General Electric plant, and a local veterinarian.

and technology. Each student attends three 50-minute workshops. There are

three workshops offered for accompanying teachers and counselors designed

to provide them with information on ways they can positively motivate and

influence young girls to achieve in the study of math. Student workshop presentations include hands-on experiments and problem-solving type activities that encourage and challenge the participants to use mathematical applications, and which will demonstrate the importance of math in all areas.

personal and anecdotal information on their own career choices, how math has shaped their choices and college studies, and the world of work.

their organization’s products and/or purpose. To involve students in learning about the displays, a trivia contest is provided, and students must ask questions about each display and must interact with each exhibitor.

of the day’s events). The goodie bags are made up of donated items, including a scientific calculator.

 

 

 

Program Expansion

 

Because we have received so much community and university support for our annual Math Options Program in attendance, participation and financially, the Math Options Committee made a recommendation to expand our programming to include a math and science summer camp. In July of 1999, Penn State Erie, in partnership with the local Girl Scouts, will host its first annual summer math and science camp for girls ages 11-15. This three-day overnight camp will provide project-type activities designed to build on the skills and interests gleaned from the Math Options Career Day, as well as math games, contests, and recreational activities. It will also provide opportunity for young women to experience the college environment, and to see engineering, computer, psychology and science labs, and interact with university staff and students.

 

Other goals for program expansion are:

 

 

Topics will include:

 

 

Offering a weekend Math Options conference-type event each year in addition to the annual career day for girls 6th through 10th grade which will include parents. Special programming will be provided for parents. The addition of this event will allow for more student involvement, and will give us opportunity to address parents on the issue.

 

 

Program Evaluation and Assessment: Long-term

 

We have developed a short-term evaluation process for the Math Options Program; however, we have established a goal to conduct long-term assessment in order to track student participants on the relevance of Math Options participation to middle and high school math and science study choices, as well as the importance of role modeling and peer mentoring.

 

Our short-term program assessments have been very valuable and effective in our program planning each year. Each year’s program has seen improvement in terms of workshop development, community participation, logistical methods, and awareness by the University on program goals and objectives. Now we need to move to the next level: assessing the long-term impact of our program.

 

 

Community Interest and Demand for Math Options

 

We are very fortunate to have broad community support and positive recognition of our Math Options Program, especially from educators who have asked us to increase our programming even further to involve more students, parents, and teachers. It is my hope that the NSF sponsored workshop will be a forum that will provide information on other nation-wide programs that are offered on this subject, and that I, as Program Coordinator, will learn how to develop an effective long-term assessment plan.

 

I, in turn, will be able to provide information on our own programming here at Penn State, what works, what has not, and to share information on how we have involved our community in this project.