Her HonorGovernor Should Turn Down Free RideTuesday, Oct. 23, 2012There should be an adage for public figures: “there is no such thing as a free ride.” Colorado Governor John Hickenlooper recently accepted a Chrysler Ram 1500 plug-in hybrid pickup truck from officials at Tri-State Generation, a utility company. His only obligation is to keep track of mileage and maintenance, and allow Chrysler to interview divers who use the vehicle. The Colorado Independent Ethics Commission ruled the gift was offered to the governor’s office, not the governor, so it does not violate the state’s gift ban. In the advisory opinion, the commission provided what I think is good reason for him to decline the offer of the vehicle. “The commission is concerned about the appearance of impropriety that could arise in the context of this arrangement. Tri-State is a high-profile business in the state that is active in public policy, including robust representation in administrative proceedings ad at the legislature.” Hickenlooper’s office argues the transparency of the contract should avoid any appearance of impropriety, but I doubt the public is focusing on the contract. What they see is the state’s top elected official getting a free ride and appearing to endorse a product – a troubling perception for taxpayers and a slippery slope for the governor.
Posted by Judy Nadler
Tags: gifts
Subscribe by emailSubscribe by email |
| |


Comments

One could argue that because the fuel, maintenance, and depreciation costs are no longer taxpayer responsibility, acceptance of this gift is a good idea. On the other hand, it could also be said that accepting a gift from someone who does business with the state sets up a conflict of interest.
Will this send the message to other businesses or vendors that the governor's office is willing and happy to accept gifts? For some, that might translate into a quid pro quo, even if there is no outright demand for special treatment. Is this implying you must "pay to play?" Does this suggest a product endorsement, and if so, how do the makers of other vehicles feel when the governor drives a Ram?
The fact that the ethics commission admits there is a perception problem should send a signal to the administration that there may be more harm than good in accepting this truck. Just because it is allowed doesn't mean it's the right thing to do.